Reading: 1 Samuel 16:6-13 – Do Not Look on His Appearance
Prayer of Confession: “Gracious God, we confess to profiling one another. … When Samuel sized up Jesse’s sons by their appearance you reminded him that ‘God looks on the heart.’ Though David’s heart was imperfect, you saw that he was capable of both righteousness and wrong. Do we trust in the capacity of all people to glorify you? Or do we approach each other assuming or suspecting harm? Forgive us, O God. Heal our reliance on superficial impressions by giving us your grace; through Jesus Christ our Savior. Amen.”
Question: Have you ever realized your first impressions of a person were wrong?
“You never get a second chance to make a first impression.”
The statement is rarely untrue. It has happened to me a couple of times: a couple of my summer band clinic teaching colleagues struck me slightly the wrong way at first, but in the intervening years of working alongside them, I have grasped why they struck me that way; and they’ve come to be among my favorite people in that role.
There was one teaching instance in which I desperately wanted to be on the positive end of that phrase, as I related to a bunch of new students … and I experienced a harrowing moment of first-impressionism from them that had nothing to do with their personalities or abilities, and it made me Very Very Nervous, and more than a little upset with myself. Not so much because of how I’d behaved, but instead because of what I thought I might have been revealed to be, deeper down.
In this case, it wasn’t necessarily that my first impressions of a person or persons were wrong; that’s not the right word… oh, how do I explain this, other than diving right in? By diving right in:
I’m a middle-aged white guy. I grew up in a town that was a bit diverse, but not very. I did attend a university whose student body looked like the United Nations if you walked past the graduate research building, but which often looked a lot more white than not. And the towns in which I taught (and currently do my church-music-making) were and are, well, not wildly diverse.
In the late 1990s, I worked as one of the instructors for a summer band program for Boston high school students, sponsored by the Boston Police Department, which met at Madison Park High School in Roxbury. The Crosstown Band consisted of about thirty high school kids from the city: two were white, one was Asian, two were Latinx, and the rest were African-American. It was the first time I’d gotten to spend extended time as (nearly) the only white guy in the room.
At the time, I mused, hmm… this must be what it’s like to be a minority. Because mathematically, I was.
And when the three white guys who were the instructional staff chanced to venture across the street from Madison Park, to grab a bite to eat … it was really obvious: we were in the minority, all right. We certainly didn’t have to imagine that people were taking a good hard look at us.
But still: Greg and Dave and I were in the minority, but we weren’t Minorities. Let’s just say that we didn’t get the same kind of good hard look as a lot of people of color get, when they pop into the supermarket in a predominantly-white part of the world. No indeed.
And at the time, I simply didn’t get it.
Now, one of the things about me, which I would like one day to wake up and discover is much better now, is my ability to quickly connect names and faces. Or lack of ability. I’m great at remembering faces; but attaching names to them very often requires more than just “hi, I’m so-and-so”, one time. I have a couple of colleagues who possess a supernatural level of ability in this area; not me.
So, in the first few days of my Crosstown Band experience, whenever the kids were holding their instruments, I was in pretty good shape: “oh yes, that’s Andre the trombone; that’s Maria the trumpet.” But at lunch? No instruments… no clue.
Bad enough that on day three I was still struggling. Far worse, I felt, after a cheerful start on Monday, that as I drove home Wednesday afternoon, all I could think of was … without their instruments, I was having a devil of a time telling some of them apart.
“They all look alike to me” …
That’s the poisonous phrase that historically has been invoked by white persons who have looked over (metaphorically or actually) at African-American persons, and implied that there was no point in thinking of them as individuals; that they weren’t worthy of the time and attention that one would devote to a full individual human.
Oh heck no!
I recoiled from this realization. Partly because as it happened, every one of those band kids (as is typical of band kids) was absolutely an individual – with a personality as big as the room they were playing in. I liked them all a ton, from the get-go. And yet early on … some of the ones that, um, didn’t have the same color skin as I had … remained an identification mystery to me.
But mostly, I recoiled from that realization because, as Jeff Lance wrote about earlier this week in this space … after having believed I was the 1990s version of “woke” … I suddenly felt like wasn’t as actively anti-racist as I wanted to be.
Now, to be clear, by Friday afternoon, I was up to speed, and certainly so was the Band (kids could play a little bit!). But that had been a very uncomfortable Wednesday afternoon and evening for a fellow who had grown up in a pretty white part of the world, but who had dutifully sung the (now-uncomfortable) Sunday School lyric “Red and yellow, black and white / They are precious in His sight” as a little kid. Who had grown up certain (thanks to his Sunday School teachers, and lots of other role models) that the lyric was true.
And had had that certainty suddenly and uncomfortably challenged. By his own facial-recognition software’s shortcomings.
I’ve had twenty years to calm down from the experience. I’m not quite calmed down yet; and it may be just as productive to keep hold of that memory and not be entirely calm about it yet.
As John Wesley mused, we’re “going on to perfection.” I’m not there yet. But I aspire.
-Rob Hammerton